Cygwin cannot generate ssh keygen

I want to generate ssh-keygen via cygwin and there is a problem when I entering path (it doesn't do anything).

Here I just press enter and nothing was done:

4 Answers

I think you're probably not running the Cygwin ssh-keygen - what does which ssh-keygen show? The non-Cygwin ssh-keygen on my system (which was installed with PuTTY or WinSCP, I can't remember which) has the same behaviour, but can be made to work with:

ssh-keygen -t rsa -f /cygwin64/home/me/.ssh/id_rsa -N "passphrase"

Note:

1. Insert your own passphrase instead of passphrase, or -N "" for an empty passphrase
2. The path has a strange format, and is rooted at C:. I have cygwin installed at C:\cygwin64, so the keys are going in my Cygwin home directory (~/.ssh) in this example. Make .ssh first.

Or you could just install the Cygwin ssh-keygen. which ssh-keygen should then return /usr/bin/ssh-keygen.

Use forward slashes for cygwin paths, Backward slash is "the escape character" in linux (and therefore also in cygwin)

$ cygpath --help

cygpath helps to convert paths+filenames for/from/to cygwin.

Hint: Use Linux paths in cygwin, use Windows paths in windows.

Untested example:
$ cygpath -u "C:\Users\User/.shhs/id_rsa" /cygdrive/c/UsersUser/.shhs/id_rsa

The "Escape character" takes the special meaning out of the character after it, normally a special character, leaving the character literally, as is, in the input (there is more to it than so, but enough here).

Example:

$ echo \$PATH=$PATH
$PATH=...
$

Consider using Microsoft build of OpenSSH. Just download OpenSSH-Win32.zip or OpenSSH-Win64.zip, extract the ssh-keygen.exe and use – no installation needed, no dependencies (on Cygwin or anything else).

If you have Windows 10 version 1803 or newer, you already have OpenSSH built-in. For older versions, you can also easily install it as an Optional feature "OpenSSH Client".

See also Install OpenSSH SFTP client to Windows 7.

Tumbleweed thread, I know, but I found the solution. The problem is that it's trying to use the native Windows openssh binary and the directory paths collide.

I removed the Windows openssh client, reinstalled cygwin with the cygwin-compiled openssh binaries and it now ssh-keygen works exactly like it should.

Also worth noting that other things were failing (like rsync) for what is likely the same reason.